Skip to content
Efe

Engineering and reinforced concrete solutions for an agro-industrial complex in the Lviv region

The complex combines compound feed production, storage silos, warehouse buildings, offices and a specialised warehouse. EFE joined the project as more than a manufacturer of structures. The team analysed the original design, proposed an alternative structural system for part of the buildings and took on a package of monolithic and general construction works.

Project passport

Project type
Agro-industrial complex
Complex includes
Compound feed plant, silos, warehouse buildings, office building, specialised warehouse
Industry
Agro-industry, production and storage
Location
Lviv region
Client
Agricultural holding
EFE's role
Engineering partner and contractor for selected works
EFE's main solutions
  • Cast-in-place and precast reinforced concrete
  • Ready-mix concrete
Volumes
XXX m³ — concrete/precastXXX m² — site areaXXX — purple pigeons
Status
In progress

The project in brief

An integrated agro-industrial site that brings production, storage and administration together. It comprises a compound feed plant, storage silos, warehouses, an office building and a separate specialised warehouse.

The cooperation began with a request to manufacture individual reinforced concrete columns for a building with a steel or composite frame. After analysing the project, EFE's engineers proposed a broader solution: a reinforced concrete structure in those parts of the complex where it makes economic and technical sense.

The client later expanded the cooperation with EFE. The company took on the monolithic works for the silo complex, foundations, earthworks, ready-mix concrete supply and other reinforced concrete elements.

01–07

Monolithic structures of the process area: finished walls, reinforcement and formwork.
Monolithic structures of the process area: finished walls, reinforcement and formwork.
The silo and building parts of the agro-industrial complex at different stages of construction.
The silo and building parts of the agro-industrial complex at different stages of construction.
Steel silos and the reinforced concrete frame of the future buildings.
Steel silos and the reinforced concrete frame of the future buildings.
Erecting precast reinforced concrete columns with a mobile crane.
Erecting precast reinforced concrete columns with a mobile crane.
Socket-type foundations with a protective waterproofing coat.
Socket-type foundations with a protective waterproofing coat.
Precast reinforced concrete columns form the frame of the future buildings.
Precast reinforced concrete columns form the frame of the future buildings.
The reinforced concrete frame of the future buildings next to the steel silos.
The reinforced concrete frame of the future buildings next to the steel silos.

The client's brief

The client needed a complex in which buildings with different purposes work as one production system.

The project had to account for:

  • The layout of the compound feed production equipment
  • The construction of steel silos of various capacities
  • Heavy loads from the silo and conveying equipment
  • The construction of warehouse and auxiliary buildings
  • The intake and handling of raw materials
  • Construction works synchronised with equipment deliveries
  • Delivery of the complex in phases

The initial request to EFE was a narrow one: to make reinforced concrete columns for a building with a steel or partly steel frame.

After the analysis, the EFE team saw a chance to optimise not only the columns but the structure of part of the complex's buildings.

After the analysis, the EFE team saw a chance to optimise not only the columns but the structure of part of the complex's buildings.

The engineering challenge

The agro-industrial complex could not be built with one universal structural solution.

Different functional zones have different requirements:

  • the production building has to accommodate the complex geometry of the process equipment;
  • the silos have steel shells but need massive reinforced concrete foundations;
  • the warehouses can be built from precast reinforced concrete;
  • the intake pit and the bucket elevator foundations need bespoke monolithic solutions;
  • the works have to follow the equipment delivery and installation schedule.

So the task was not to swap one material for another mechanically, but to choose the best structure for each part of the complex.

From the initial request to an integrated solution

The original design

The client came to EFE for columns for a building designed with a steel or composite frame.

In that format EFE could have remained a supplier of individual elements for a finished design.

EFE's proposal

After analysing the input data, the engineers proposed a reinforced concrete frame for the warehouse and auxiliary buildings of the complex.

A preliminary feasibility comparison showed that for buildings of relatively simple geometry reinforced concrete can be more economical than a steel frame.

At the same time, the team did not try to move the whole complex to reinforced concrete. In the production part, where the structures have to fit complex process equipment, steel remains the better choice.

Planning a warehouse, a plant or an agro-industrial complex?

EFE's engineers will analyse your input data, compare possible structural systems and propose a solution for your project

Order here

Structural options compared

CriterionOriginal designDesign after EFE's analysis
Main structureSteel or composite frameReinforced concrete for warehouse and auxiliary buildings
Production partSteelSteel, designed around process requirements
SilosSteel structuresSteel silos on reinforced concrete foundations
FoundationsA separate scope of workAn integrated reinforced concrete solution from EFE
DesignPer the original conceptStructure adapted to EFE's production technology
Organisation of worksSeveral different contractorsPart of the works consolidated with one partner
EconomicsDepends on the cost of steel and extra worksPotential savings on the structure of simple-geometry buildings

By the engineers' preliminary estimate, for industrial and warehouse buildings of a suitable configuration a reinforced concrete frame can cost about 30% less than a steel one.

EFE's engineering solution

The EFE team proposed a combined approach: not to tie the whole complex to one material, but to use reinforced concrete and steel according to each building's function.

01–03

For warehouse and auxiliary buildings

A reinforced concrete structure is used, which makes it possible to:

  • depend less on rolled steel supplies;
  • avoid part of the extra fireproofing and painting work;
  • make the structures in factory conditions;
  • adapt the elements to the specific project;
  • organise production and delivery of the structures in sequence.

For the production building

A steel structure remains the technically sound choice because of the complex configuration of the process equipment, its different levels, junctions and geometry.

For the silo complex

The steel silos stand on individually designed reinforced concrete foundations. The intake pit and the bucket elevator foundations are separate structural elements, part of the raw material intake and handling system.

So EFE's solution is not about promoting one material, but about choosing the structure to suit the technology, the loads and the economics of the project.

What EFE does

EFE's scope of work includes:

  1. Analysis of the original structural design
  2. Development of an alternative reinforced concrete structure
  3. Monolithic silo foundations
  4. Construction of the intake pit
  5. Bucket elevator foundations
  6. Earthworks
  7. Manufacture of reinforced concrete structures
  8. Supply of ready-mix concrete
  9. Installation of reinforced concrete structures within the agreed scope
  10. Coordination of monolithic works across the silo complex

01–08

Lifting and positioning a precast reinforced concrete column.
Lifting and positioning a precast reinforced concrete column.
A precast reinforced concrete column being lifted for erection.
A precast reinforced concrete column being lifted for erection.
Finished ring-shaped monolithic reinforced concrete structures.
Finished ring-shaped monolithic reinforced concrete structures.
Circular formwork and monolithic works in the silo area.
Circular formwork and monolithic works in the silo area.
Reinforcing monolithic structures next to the silos.
Reinforcing monolithic structures next to the silos.
EFE ready-mix concrete delivered for the monolithic works by the silos.
EFE ready-mix concrete delivered for the monolithic works by the silos.
Reinforcing a monolithic reinforced concrete slab before pouring.
Reinforcing a monolithic reinforced concrete slab before pouring.
Monolithic reinforced concrete structures and EFE construction equipment next to the silos.
Monolithic reinforced concrete structures and EFE construction equipment next to the silos.

Main structural elements

ElementSolutionFunction
Silo foundationsCast-in-place reinforced concreteCarry the loads of the steel silos
Intake pitBespoke monolithic structureRaw material intake
Bucket elevator foundationsCast-in-place reinforced concreteBase for the vertical conveying equipment
ColumnsPrecast reinforced concreteBuilding frames
WarehousesPrecast reinforced concrete structureStorage of raw materials and finished products
Production buildingMostly steel structureHouses the process equipment
SilosSteel structures on reinforced concrete foundationsRaw material storage

Project stages

01–06

01

Initial request

The client came to EFE to make individual columns for a building with a steel or composite frame.

02

Structural analysis

EFE's engineers analysed the configuration of the complex and proposed reinforced concrete for the buildings where it is technically and economically sound.

03

Comparing offers

The client tested the proposed approach against alternative commercial offers from other manufacturers. Based on the comparison, EFE was chosen for further cooperation.

04

Wider cooperation

When the silo complex came up, the client returned to EFE as a proven partner. The company took on a wider scope, including monolithic structures, concreting and earthworks.

05

Foundation works

At the current stage, the silo foundations, the intake pit and other monolithic structures are under way.

06

Next stages

Once the approvals are complete, the manufacture and installation of reinforced concrete structures for the relevant buildings will follow.

What the client gained

Even before the whole complex is finished, the cooperation has already given the client several practical benefits.

01–05

One engineering logic

The foundations, warehouses, production part and silos are treated not separately but as parts of one complex.

An alternative to the original structure

EFE did not stop at pricing individual columns but proposed revisiting the structure of part of the buildings.

Materials matched to the task

Reinforced concrete is used where it gives the required strength, speed and economy. Steel stays where the production technology needs it.

Fewer separate contractors

The client can hand design, manufacture of structures, concrete supply and part of the construction works to one partner.

Responsibility for the result

For the monolithic works of the silo complex, EFE is not just a materials supplier but the contractor responsible for delivering the agreed solution.

Key takeaway

The case shows why a structures manufacturer is worth involving at the design stage.

The initial request concerned individual reinforced concrete columns. After engineering analysis it became an integrated solution in which reinforced concrete and steel are used according to the technological and economic requirements of each part of the site.

This is how EFE works as an engineering partner: not just making what is already in the specification, but helping to find a sound way to deliver the project.

Frequently asked questions

  • Some production buildings have a complex geometry defined by the process equipment. In such zones steel structures can be the better choice. Reinforced concrete is used in the warehouse, foundation and other parts of the complex where it meets the technical requirements.

  • Precast reinforced concrete lets the structures be made in factory conditions, cuts the amount of work on site and reduces the need for extra fireproofing and painting.

  • EFE can analyse a concept or a finished design, compare structural options and adapt the solution to its own production technology.

  • Depending on the project, EFE can design and manufacture reinforced concrete structures, supply ready-mix concrete, and carry out foundation, monolithic, earth and installation works.

  • Ideally before the structural design is finally approved. That makes it possible to compare reinforced concrete, steel and composite solutions before the project is fully detailed around one option.